Appeal Number:
OPA-PA-09-005
Appeal Relative to:
(GCIF vs. DPW) re: RFP No. 700-5-1020-L-TAM- Construction of new John F. Kennedy High School, finance, demolition, design, build, maintain and leaseba
Appellant:
Guam Community Improvement Foundation
Purchasing Agency:
- Department of Public Works
Appeal Received:
Wednesday, August 26, 2009 - 1:30pm
Appeal Status:
- Decision
Type of Appeal:
- Method of Solicitation or Award
Procurement Record Due:
Thursday, September 3, 2009 - 10:15am
Procurement Record Filed:
Wednesday, September 2, 2009 - 1:45pm
Scheduling Order Filed:
Wednesday, September 16, 2009 - 4:00pm
Motions Filed:
Friday, September 18, 2009 - 5:00pm
Response to Motions Due:
Friday, September 25, 2009 - 5:00pm
Agency Report Due:
Friday, September 11, 2009 - 10:15am
Agency Report Filed:
Friday, September 11, 2009 - 4:45pm
Comments On Agency Report Due:
Monday, September 21, 2009 - 4:45pm
Comments on Agency Report Filed:
Monday, September 21, 2009 - 2:45pm
Pre-Hearing:
Friday, October 9, 2009 - 9:00am
Tentative Hearing Date:
Monday, October 26, 2009 - 9:00am
Decision Due:
Friday, November 27, 2009 - 12:00am
Decision Filed:
Friday, November 27, 2009 - 6:00pm
Remarks:
Important Update:
The Public Auditor's Decision relative to Appeal No. OPA-PA-09-005 was issued on Friday, November 27, 2009.
The Public Auditor's Decision relative to Appeal No. OPA-PA-09-005 was issued on Friday, November 27, 2009.
*MP3's are displayed through audio players. Other audio file types are displayed as links. You may need a player installed in your device to play certain audio files for non-MP3's.
File Name
Access/Download File
File Size / File Type
Notice of Appeal
Download Notice_of_Appeal.pdf (40.96 MB) - PDF Decision
Download 09-005_Decision.pdf (1.36 MB) - PDF Decision and Order Re Purchasing Agency's Motion For Protective Order 10/21/09 ( )
Decision and Order Re Purchasing Agency's Motion For Confirmation of Substantial Interest
Notice of Receipt of Appeal
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org Notice of Receipt of Appeal 0.pdf
Download Notice_of_Receipt_of_Appeal.pdf (9.98 MB) Download Notice_of_Receipt_of_Appeal.pdf (9.98 MB) - PDF Audio Record: Status and Scheduling Hearing, 09/15/09
(31.66 MB ) - WAV
Hearing Request
Download Hearing_Request.pdf (96.71 KB) - PDF Audio Record: Pre-Hearing Conference, 10/09/09
(31.58 MB ) - WAV
Declaration of Substantial Interest
Download 09-005_Declaration_of_Substantial_Interest.pdf (2.02 MB) - PDF Notification Notice of Appeal to Interested Party
Download 09-005_Notification_Notice_of_Appeal_to_Interested_Party.pdf (494.15 KB) - PDF Procurement Record Transmittal
Download 09-005_Procurement_Record_Transmittal.pdf (110.69 KB) - PDF Entry of Appearance - Benjamin Abrams
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 09-005 Entry of Appearance 0.pdf
Download 09-005_Entry_of_Appearance.pdf (68.86 KB) Download 09-005_Entry_of_Appearance.pdf (68.86 KB) - PDF Memorandum Re: Declaration of Substantial Interest
Download 09-005_Memorandum_Re_Declaration_of_Substantial_Interest.pdf (319.72 KB) - PDF Notice of Status and Scheduling Conference
Download 09-005_Notice_of_Status_and_Scheduling_Conference.pdf (229.67 KB) - PDF Second Notice of Status and Scheduling Conference
Download 09-005_Second_Notice_of_Status_and_Scheduling.pdf (265.82 KB) - PDF Agency Report
Download 09-005_Agency_Report.pdf (14.81 MB) - PDF Notice of Hearing and Scheduling Order For the Purchasing Agency's Motions to Seal Portions of Procurement Record and For Confirmation of Substantial Interests and Notice of Pre-Hearing Conference
Entry of Appearance - Civille & Tang, PLLC
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 09-005 Entry of Apperance 0.pdf
Download 09-005_Entry_of_Apperance.pdf (55.26 KB) Download 09-005_Entry_of_Apperance.pdf (55.26 KB) - PDF Motion for Protective Order; Supporting Memorandum of Points & Authorities Part 1
Download DOC038.PDF (3.33 MB) - PDF Motion for Protective Order; Supporting Memorandum of Points & Authorities Part 2
Download DOC039.PDF (5.08 MB) - PDF Motion for Protective Order; Supporting Memorandum of Points & Authorities Part 3
Download DOC040.PDF (4.9 MB) - PDF Motion for Protective Order; Supporting Memorandum of Points & Authorities Part 4
Download DOC041.PDF (4.17 MB) - PDF Appellee's Witness & Exhibit Lists
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 09-005 Appellee%27s Witness List 0.pdf
Download 09-005_Appellee's_Witness_List.pdf (97.69 KB) Download 09-005_Appellee's_Witness_List.pdf (97.69 KB) - PDF Appellee's Additional Exhibit
Download 09-005_Appellee's_Additional_Exhibit.pdf (164.09 KB) - PDF Appellant's_Exhibit_List
Download 09-005_Appellant's_Exhibit_List.pdf (5.88 MB) - PDF Comment of International Bridge Corporation, as an Interested Party, to the Agency Report Filed Sept. 11, 2009
Reply to Appellant's Memo RE: Declaration of Substantial Interest
Augmentation of Procurement Record Transmittal
Download 09-005_Augmentation_of_Procurement_Record_Transmittal.pdf (76.05 KB) - PDF Appellant's Response to Motion for a Protective Order by Purchasing Agency
Designation by Nerissa Bretania Underwood, Ph.D., of Arlene Unpingco
The Government's Reply to Response for a Protective Order
Download 09-005_Governments_Reply_to_Response_for_Protective_Order.PDF (302.78 KB) - PDF Notice of Rescheduled Pre-hearing Conference
Download 09-005_Request_For_Extension_of_Time.pdf (104.92 KB) - PDF Declaration of John Weisenberger
Download 09-005_Declaration_of__John_Weisenberger.pdf (1.36 MB) - PDF Declaration of John Weisenberger 2
Download 09-005_Declaration_of_John_Weisenberger_2.pdf (163.95 KB) - PDF Scheduling Order Re Hearing For Appellant's Appeal
Download 09-005_Scheduling_Order_Re_Hearing_For_Appellant's_Appeal.pdf (128.64 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Mr. Ho S. Eun, President, Core Tech Inc.
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Mr._Ho_S._Eun_President_Core_Tech_Inc..pdf (77.57 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Mr. Tony Sgro, President, GCIF Inc.
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Mr._Tony_Sgro_President_GCIF_Inc..pdf (81.35 KB) - PDF Appellant's Witness List [for 10/26/09 Formal Hearing]
Download 09-005_Appellants_Witness_List_Formal_Hearing.pdf (75.37 KB) - PDF Appellant's Exhibit List [for 10/26/09 Formal Hearing]
Download 09-005_Appellant's_Exhibit_List_Formal_Hearing.pdf (72.26 KB) - PDF Appellant's Trail Brief [for 10/26/09 Formal Hearing]
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 09-005 Appelant%27s Trial Brief 0.pdf
Download 09-005_Appelant's_Trial_Brief.pdf (207.8 KB) Download 09-005_Appelant's_Trial_Brief.pdf (207.8 KB) - PDF Appellee's Witness and Exhibit List [for 10/26/09 Formal Hearing]
Download 09-005_Appellee's_Witness_and_Exhibit_Lists_Formal_Hearing.pdf (169.52 KB) - PDF Admissions of Fact List of Contested Issues
Appellee's Hearing Brief [for 10/26/09 Formal Hearing]
Download 09-005_Appellee's_Hearing_Brief_Formal_Hearing.pdf (170.83 KB) - PDF Notice of Hearing Re Appellant's Appeal
Download 09-005_Notice_of_Hearing_Re_Appellant's_Appeal.pdf (122.51 KB) - PDF Amended Witness List [for 10/26/09 Formal Hearing]
Download 09-005_Amended_Witness_List_Formal_Hearing.pdf (62.08 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Nerissa Bretania Underwood
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Nerissa_Bretania_Underwood.pdf (78.79 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Fred Nishihara
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 09-005 Subpoena Fred Nishihara 0.pdf
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Fred_Nishihara.pdf (74.14 KB) Download 09-005_Subpoena_Fred_Nishihara.pdf (74.14 KB) - PDF Supooena (Corrected) - Dana Figirliyong
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Corrected_Dana_Figirliyong.pdf (75.54 KB) - PDF Subpoena (Corrected) - Collette Beausoliel
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Corrected_Collette_Beausoliel.pdf (80.63 KB) - PDF Appellant's Motion To Reconsider Protective Order
Download 09-005_Appellant's_Motion_To_Reconsider_Protective_Order.pdf (247.61 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Dept. of Revenue & Taxation Custodian of Records
Download 09-005_Subpoena_RevTax_Custodian_of_Records.pdf (109.43 KB) - PDF Supboena - Geraldine James
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 09-005 Subpoena Geraldine James 0.pdf
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Geraldine_James.pdf (85.66 KB) Download 09-005_Subpoena_Geraldine_James.pdf (85.66 KB) - PDF Subpoena Duces Tecum - Andrew Leon Guerrero
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Duces_Tecum_Andrew_Leon_Guerrero.pdf (109.36 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Doreen Crisostomo
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Doreen_Crisostomo.pdf (96.67 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Eunice Aflague
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 09-005 Subpoena Eunice Aflague 0.pdf
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Eunice_Aflague.pdf (116.47 KB) Download 09-005_Subpoena_Eunice_Aflague.pdf (116.47 KB) - PDF Subpoena - Gayle Hendricks
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 09-005 Subpoena Gayle Hendricks 0.pdf
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Gayle_Hendricks.pdf (80.37 KB) Download 09-005_Subpoena_Gayle_Hendricks.pdf (80.37 KB) - PDF Opposition of Interested Party International Bridge Corporation to Appellant's Motion to Reconsider Protective Order
Second Augmentation Procurement Record Transmittal - Cover Page
Joinder in IBC Opposition to Appellant's Motion to Reconsider Protective Order
Subpoena Duces Tecum - Dan Moffat
Download 09-005_Subpoena_Duces_Tecum_Dan_Moffat.pdf (91.07 KB) - PDF Joinder in IBC Opposition to Appellant's Motion to Reconsider Protective Order 2
Procurement Record Transmittal - Proposers Presentations -Protected Audio Records
Subpoena - Doreen Crisostomo - 2
Download 09_005_Subpoena_Doreen_Crisostomo_2.pdf (73.63 KB) - PDF Interested Party IBC's Statement Re Remedies
Download 09-005_Interested_Party_IBC's_Statement_Re_Remedies.pdf (363.72 KB) - PDF Department of Public Works Statement Re Remedies
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 09-005 DPW%27s Statement Re Remedies 0.pdf
Download 09-005_DPW's_Statement_Re_Remedies.pdf (172.22 KB) Download 09-005_DPW's_Statement_Re_Remedies.pdf (172.22 KB) - PDF Procurement Officer's Determination and Certification
