Appeal Number:
OPA-PA-19-011
Appeal Relative to:
Nutrition Services for the Comprehensive Management, Operations, and Maintenance of the Elderly Nutrition Program, Congregate Meals and Home-Delivered
Appellant:
Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation
Purchasing Agency:
- General Services Agency
Appeal Received:
Monday, December 16, 2019 - 4:25pm
Appeal Status:
- Decision
Type of Appeal:
- Decision on Protest of Method, Solicitation or Award
Procurement Record Due:
Tuesday, December 24, 2019 - 5:00pm
Agency Report Due:
Thursday, January 2, 2020 - 5:00pm
*MP3's are displayed through audio players. Other audio file types are displayed as links. You may need a player installed in your device to play certain audio files for non-MP3's.
File Name
Access/Download File
File Size / File Type
Decision - December 11, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_and_20-003_decision.pdf (206.5 KB) - PDF Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Proposed Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law - October 16, 2020
S.H. Enterprises, Inc.'s Proposed Findings of Facts and Conclusions of Law - October 16, 2020
GSA Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law - October 16, 2020
SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Brief RE Remedies - October 16, 2020
Basil Food Industrial Services Response to Purchasing Agency's Notice of Supplemental Authority - September 30, 2020
Purchasing Agency's Notice of Supplemental Authority - September 23, 2020
Third Amended Notice of Hearing RE Appellant’s Appeal - September 15, 2020
Fourth Status Conference - September 15, 2020
(3.03 MB ) - M4A
Notice of Fourth Status Conference - September 10, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_and_20-003_notice_of_fourth_status_conference.pdf (117.56 KB) - PDF Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Remedies Brief - August 18, 2020
SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Supplemental Exhibit List - August 18, 2020
Second Amended Notice of Hearing RE Appellant's Appeal - August 17, 2020
Amended Notice of Third Status Conference - August 13, 2020
Notice of Third Status Conference - August 11, 2020
Notice of Erratum to Purchasing Agency's Hearing Brief on the Merits - August 10, 2020
Purchasing Agency's Supplemental Exhibit M (RE Basil Protest Notice Dated February 7, 2020) - August 10, 2020
Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Hearing Brief - August 7, 2020
Interested Party SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Hearing Brief - August 7, 2020
Interested Party SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Reply Brief RE Jurisdiction - August 7, 2020
Purchasing Agency's Hearing Brief on the Merits - August 7, 2020
Purchasing Agency's Brief on Jurisdiction - August 7, 2020
Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Brief on the Issue of Jurisdiction - August 3, 2020
SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Witness List - July 31, 2020
SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Exhibit List - July 31, 2020
Appellant Basil Food industrial Services Corporations's List of Issues - July 31, 2020
Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Witness List - July 31, 2020
Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Exhibit List - July 31, 2020
SH Enterprises, Inc.'s List of Issues
Order After Hearing - July 29, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_and_20-003_order_after_hearing.pdf (273.09 KB) - PDF Hearing on Purchasing Agency's Motion for Summary Judgement - July 29, 2020
(18.61 MB ) - M4A
Notice of Hearing RE Purchasing Agency's Motion for Summary Judgement - July 14, 2020
Amended Order Reversing Recusal of Public Auditor and Appointment and Designation of Hearing Officer to Preside Over Appeals - July 10, 2020
Letter from Appellant Basil Food Seeking Clarification on Order Reversing Recusal of Public Auditor and Appointment and Designation of Hearing Officer to Preside Over Appeals
Order Reversing Recusal of Public Auditor and Appointment and Designation of Hearing Officer to Preside Over Appeals - July 9, 2020
GSA's Motion for Summary Judgment; Memorandum of Points and Authorities -July 8, 2020
Notice of Disqualification of Procurement Appeals Hearing Officer Anthony Camacho - July 7, 2020
Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Opposition to GSA's Motion for Summary Judgment Dated June 10, 2020 - July 1, 2020
First Amended Scheduling Order - June 11, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_and_20-003_first_amended_scheduling_order.pdf (178.99 KB) - PDF First Amended Notice of Hearing RE Appellant's Appeal - June 11, 2020
GSA's Motion for Summary Judgement; Memorandum of Points and Authorities - June 10, 2020
Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Request for Hearing - May 29, 2020
Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Comments to Agency Report - May 29, 2020
Request for Hearing Made by General Services Agency - May 29, 2020
OPA-PA-19-011 and 20-003 Second Status Conference - May 26, 2020
(10.4 MB ) - M4A
Notice of Second Status Conference - May 14, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_and_20-003_notice_of_second_status_hearing.pdf (141.38 KB) - PDF Purchasing Agency GSA's List of Issues - March 13, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_purchasing_agency_gsas_list_of_issues.pdf (39.99 KB) - PDF Purchasing Agency GSA's Witness List - March 13, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_purchasing_agency_gsas_witness_list.pdf (39.16 KB) - PDF Purchasing Agency GSA's Exhibit List - March 13, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_purchasing_agency_gsas_exhibit_list.pdf (57.17 KB) - PDF Notice of Status Hearing - March 13, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-001_and_20-003_notice_of_status_hearing.pdf (112.74 KB) - PDF Order Consolidating Appeals - March 13, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-001_and_20-003_order_consolidating_appeals.pdf (116.44 KB) - PDF Entry of Appearance - Sandra Miller, Assistant Deputy Attorney General - February 26, 2020
SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Reply to Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Opposition to SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Motion for Summary Judgment - February 14, 2020
Substitution of Counsel - February 14, 2020
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 19-011 substitution of counsel.pdf
Download 19-011_substitution_of_counsel.pdf (190.24 KB) Download 19-011_substitution_of_counsel.pdf (190.24 KB) - PDF Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Opposition to SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Motion for Summary Judgement - February 7, 2020
SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Motion for Summary Judgement; Memorandum of Points and Authorities - January 31, 2020
Declaration of Leslie Travis in Support of SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Motion for Summary Judgement - January 31, 2020
SH Enterprises, Inc.s Request for Hearing - January 21, 2020
Notice of Pre-Hearing Conference and Motion Hearing - January 17, 2020
Scheduling Order - January 17, 2020
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org opa-pa-19-011 scheduling order.pdf
Download opa-pa-19-011_scheduling_order.pdf (118.8 KB) Download opa-pa-19-011_scheduling_order.pdf (118.8 KB) - PDF Notice of Hearing RE Appellant's Appeal - January 17, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_notice_of_hearing_re_appellants_appeal.pdf (95.44 KB) - PDF SH Enterprises, Inc.'s Response to Agency Report - January 16, 2020
Appellant Basil Food Industrial Services Corporation's Comments on Agency Report - January 16, 2020
Agency Report (Large document - TOC only - Contact Jerrick Hernandez at 475-0390 ext. 208 to view) - January 6, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_agency_report_toc_only.pdf (10.96 KB) - PDF Notice of Status Conference - January 6, 2020
Download opa-pa-19-011_notice_of_status_conference.pdf (66.78 KB) - PDF Recusal of Public Auditor and Order Appointing and Designating Hearing Officer to Preside Over Appeal - December 31, 2019
Procurement Record (Large document - TOC only - Contact Jerrick Hernandez at 475-0390 ext. 208 to view) - December 30, 2019
Entry of Appearance - Attorneys for Interested Party SH Enterprises, Inc. - December 26, 2019
Notice of Receipt of Appeal - December 17, 2019
Download opa-pa-19-011_notice_of_receipt_of_appeal.pdf (586.32 KB) - PDF Notice of Procurement Appeal - December 16, 2019
Download opa-pa-19-011_notice_of_procurement_appeal.pdf (4.6 MB) - PDF 
