Appeal Number:
OPA-PA-16-003
Appeal Relative to:
Tourism Destination Marketing Representation Services in the Republic of Korea
Appellant:
TLK Marketing Co., Ltd.
Purchasing Agency:
- Guam Visitor's Bureau
Appeal Received:
Friday, April 22, 2016 - 4:15pm
Appeal Status:
- Decision
Type of Appeal:
- Decision on Protest of Method, Solicitation or Award
Procurement Record Due:
Monday, May 2, 2016 - 5:00pm
Agency Report Due:
Monday, May 9, 2016 - 5:00pm
*MP3's are displayed through audio players. Other audio file types are displayed as links. You may need a player installed in your device to play certain audio files for non-MP3's.
File Name
Access/Download File
File Size / File Type
Notice of Status Conference - February 4, 2019
Download opa-pa-16-003_and_16-005_notice_of_status_conference_3.pdf (119.69 KB) - PDF Amended Recusal of Public Auditor and Order Appointing OPA Auditor to Preside Over Appeal - January 3, 2019
TLK Marketing Co. Ltd.'s Objection to Appointment of Peter C. Perez' as Presiding Auditor - November 30, 2018
Declaration of Joyce C.H. Tang in Support of TLK Marketing Co. Ltd.'s Objection to Appointment of Perter C. Perez as Presiding Auditor - November 30, 2019
Notice of Status Conference - November 29, 2018
Download opa-pa-16-003_and_16-005_notice_of_status_conference.pdf (119.74 KB) - PDF Recusal of Public Auditor and Order Designating Hearing Officer to Preside Over Appeal - November 20, 2018
Decision October 3, 2016
Download 16-003_16-005_decision.pdf (4.94 MB) - PDF Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (proposed) - August 24, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law - August 24, 2016
Formal Hearing Continuation (Part D) - August 10, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Formal Hearing Continuation (Part C) - August 10, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Formal Hearing Continuation (Part B) - August 10, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Formal Hearing Continuation (Part A) - August 10, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Formal Hearing Continuation (Part C) - August 9, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Formal Hearing Continuation (Part B) - August 9, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Formal Hearing Continuation (Part A) - August 9, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Supplement to an Agency Procurement File
Supplement to an Agency Procurement File - August 4, 2016
Statement Regarding a Decision and Order - July 20, 2016
Order After Hearing - July 13, 2016
Download 16-003_16-005_order_after_hearing.pdf (381.7 KB) - PDF Formal Hearing (Part C) - July 6, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Formal Hearing (Part B) - July 6, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Formal Hearing (Part A) - July 6, 2016 (Note: Please see OPA-PA-16-005)
Declaration of Sara Rose Fitzpatrick - July 6, 2016
Download opa-pa-16-003_and_16-005_declaration_of_sara_rose_fitzpatrick.pdf (1012.31 KB) - PDF TLK Markerting Co. LTD’s Witness List for Final Hearing - July 5, 2016
TLK Marketing Co. LTD’s Exhibit List for Final Hearing (TOC Only - Large File - Contact Jerrick Hernandez at 475-0390 ext. 208) - July 5, 2016
Hearing Brief – Guam Visitors Bureau - July 5, 2016
Exhibit List – Guam Visitors Bureau - July 5, 2016
Statement of Stipulated Facts Submitted by Guam Visitors Bureau - July 5, 2016
Witness List – Guam Visitors Bureau - July 5, 2016
Notice - July 5, 2016
Download opa-pa-16-003_and_16-005_notice_.pdf (2.91 MB) - PDF Certification - July 5, 2016
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org opa-pa-16-003 certification.pdf
Download opa-pa-16-003_certification.pdf (919.5 KB) Download opa-pa-16-003_certification.pdf (919.5 KB) - PDF Proof of Service - July 5, 2016
Download opa-pa-16-003_proof_of_service.pdf (1.75 MB) - PDF TLK Marketing Co. LTD’s Hearing Brief - July 5, 2016
Guam Visitors Bureau's Rebuttal to Comments on an Agency Report - June 29, 2016
TLK Marketing Co. Ltd's Response to Agency Report - June 27, 2016
Order Consolidating Appeals/Scheduling Order - June 24, 2016
Statement Regarding a Decision and Order - June 22, 2016
Download opa-pa-16-003_statement_regarding_a_decision_and_order.pdf (932.3 KB) - PDF Decision and Order - June 15, 2016
Download opa-pa-16-003_decision_and_order.pdf (5.39 MB) - PDF Reply to Response to Motion for an Order to Supplement the Procurement Record; Motion for Discovery - June 3, 2016
Reply to Opposition to a Motion in RE a Stay - June 3, 2016
Procurement Record Second Supplement to Volume I - June 3, 2016
Reply to a Response to Agency's May 27th Submission - June 3, 2016
Erratum - June 3, 2016
Download opa-pa-16-003_erratum.pdf (374.17 KB) - PDF Response to Agency's May 27, 2016 Submission - June 1, 2016
Opposition to Motion in RE a Stay - June 1, 2016
Download opa-pa-16-003_opposition_to_a_motion_in_re_a_stay.pdf (1.26 MB) - PDF Response to Motion for an Order to Supplement the Procurement Record; Motion for Discovery - June 1, 2016
Motion for Order to Supplement Procurement Record; Motion for Discovery - May 27, 2016
Request for Subpoenas - May 27, 2016
Download opa-pa-16-003_request_for_subpoenas1.pdf (649.88 KB) - PDF Opposition to a Motion in Re a Hearing in this Matter - May 27, 2016
Rebuttal to Comments on an Agency Report - May 26, 2016
Order After Hearing/Scheduling Order - May 25, 2016
TLK Marketing Co. LTD’s Response to Agency Report - May 19, 2016
Notice of Pre-Hearing - May 13, 2016
Download opa-pa-16-003_notice_of_pre-hearing_conference.pdf (1.87 MB) - PDF Notice - March 13, 2016
Download 16-003_notice.pdf (270.71 KB) - PDF Letter from Civille & Tang, PLLC - May 13, 2016
Download opa-pa-16-003_letter_from_civille_tang_pllc.pdf (995.95 KB) - PDF Request for Expedited Hearing RE TLK Marketing’s Motion for Orders Confirming the Automatic Stay and Requiring the Guam Visitors Bureau to Issue a Final Decision on Protest 2 - May 12, 2016
Agency Report (Large File - Contact Jerrick Hernandez at 475-0390 ext 208 to view) - May 9, 2016
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org opa-pa-16-003 agency report.pdf
Download opa-pa-16-003_agency_report.pdf (259.2 KB) Download opa-pa-16-003_agency_report.pdf (259.2 KB) - PDF Motion for Orders Confirming the Automatic Stay and Requiring the Guam Visitors Bureau to Issue a Decision on Protest 2 and Request for Expedited Hearing - May 6, 2016
Declaration of Joyce C.H. Tang in Support of TLK Marketing's Motion for Orders... (Large document - Contact Jerrick Hernandez at 475-0390 ext 208 to view) - May 6, 2016
Agency Procurement Record Supplement to Vol. I - May 6, 2016
Notice of Appointment of Hearing Officer - May 4, 2016
Procurement Record Volumes I, II, and III Table of Contents Only (Large document - Contact Jerrick Hernandez at 475-0390 ext. 208 to view) - May 2, 2016
Notice of Appeal (Large document - Contact Jerrick Hernandez at 475-0390 ext. 208 to view) - April 22, 2016
https://gwosa2.opaguam.org 16-003 notice of appeal.pdf
Download 16-003_notice_of_appeal.pdf (5.18 MB) Download 16-003_notice_of_appeal.pdf (5.18 MB) - PDF Notice of Receipt of Appeal - April 25, 2016
Download 16-003_notice_of_receipt_of_appeal.pdf (3.4 MB) - PDF 
